Florida LLC Deadlock: Your Options When Owners Split 50/50
My co-owner and I are split 50/50 and stuck. What are my options? Many Florida business owners face this question, and the answer usually starts with one document: the operating agreement.
Most deadlocks are decided by what that agreement says about buy-sell rights, tie-breakers, and distributions. When the agreement is silent, or its mechanism fails, Florida law supplies three main levers: the right to see the company's records, a court order if you are refused, and, as a last resort, a petition to dissolve the company for deadlock. That petition often ends in a court-supervised buyout rather than a shutdown. The sections below explain each one.
Who this applies to, and what changes the answer
This guide is written for co-owners of a Florida LLC or closely held corporation who are split 50/50, because deadlock typically arises when decision-making power is evenly divided or the governing rules let one member block major action, and for minority owners whose distributions have stopped. It assumes the business still operates; the owners just cannot agree. It does not cover publicly traded companies, family estate disputes, or a planned exit from a company with no deadlock.
The answer for your company depends on a few facts:
- Entity type. LLCs are governed by Chapter 605, Florida Statutes, and corporations by Chapter 607. The remedies are similar, but the notice rules and deadlines differ.
- What the operating agreement says. Under section 605.0105, the agreement governs relations among the members and how the company runs. A buy-sell, tie-breaker, or distribution clause usually controls first, and voting thresholds such as unanimous or supermajority approval can create a block. A well-drafted deadlock provision creates a predictable resolution process, helps preserve relationships among Florida LLC members, and supports business continuity by reducing operational paralysis during disagreements; unclear or incomplete terms often lead to shareholder and member disputes over fiduciary duties, buyouts, and deadlock.
- Who manages the company. In a member-managed LLC, each member owes duties of loyalty and care. In a manager-managed LLC, those duties fall on the managers (section 605.04091). Records rights also differ by structure.
- Whether money is being withheld. A pure governance deadlock is a planning problem. Once distributions or information are cut off, timing starts to matter.
These disputes are heard in circuit court. For a Fort Lauderdale company, that is usually the Seventeenth Judicial Circuit, which covers Broward County; Miami-Dade is the Eleventh Circuit and Palm Beach the Fifteenth (section 26.021). A suit to inspect LLC records is filed in the county of the company's principal office (section 605.0411).
What to check first: operating agreement, deadlock sale provision, documents, dates, and records
Before you decide on a strategy, gather the full paper trail. Collect these items:
- The operating agreement and every amendment, plus any separate buy-sell or member agreement
- The articles of organization (or the articles of incorporation and bylaws for a corporation)
- The distribution history: what was paid, to whom, and when
- Capital contribution records
- Every records request you have already made, with the date it was received and any response
- Written evidence of the deadlock, such as failed votes, unanswered proposals, and emails or texts
- Recent financial statements and tax returns, including each owner's K-1
Contribution records matter more than many owners expect. If the agreement says nothing about how distributions are split, Florida shares them by the agreed value of each member's contributions as stated in the company's records (section 605.0404).
Timing matters in three places. First, an LLC that receives a proper records demand has 10 days to tell the member, in a record, what it will provide, when, and where, and why it is declining anything (section 605.0410). In a manager-managed LLC, the demand must be in a record, describe the information with reasonable particularity, and serve a purpose reasonably related to your interest as a member. Corporate shareholders must give written notice at least five business days ahead (section 607.1602).
Second, if your agreement has a deadlock sale provision and someone starts it before a court finds grounds for dissolution, that provision controls instead of dissolution or a court-ordered buyout (section 605.0702). Who moves first can matter.
Third, once a member petitions to dissolve for deadlock, the company or the other members may elect to buy that member's entire interest at fair value. The election is due within 90 days after the petition is filed, unless the court allows more time (section 605.0706; for corporations, section 607.1436).
Practical options and what changes the choice
Most owners work up a ladder, from the least drastic step to the most. Each step also builds the record for the next one.
- Negotiated buyout or restructuring. One owner buys the other out, or both agree on new governance. A buyout may preserve goodwill that liquidation would destroy, and it may also have capital gain or loss consequences. The operating agreement sets the starting terms (section 605.0105), and deadlocks that cannot be resolved privately often turn into business litigation over control, contracts, or ownership rights.
- The agreement's own deadlock mechanism. Florida recognizes deadlock-breaking provisions such as a redemption or purchase and sale of interests, a governance change, or a sale of the company, and an operating agreement resolves some disputes privately without dissolution when its buy-sell or sale process works as drafted (section 605.0702).
- A records and accounting demand. This gets you the books and distribution data you need to value the business or test the other side's conduct. If the company refuses, a court can order inspection and, unless the company shows a good-faith, reasonable basis for refusing, must make it pay your reasonable costs, including attorney's fees (section 605.0411).
- A direct claim against the other owner or manager. A member may sue to enforce the member's own rights under the operating agreement or Chapter 605 (section 605.0801), often with help from a Fort Lauderdale business law attorney experienced in South Florida ownership disputes.
- Judicial dissolution for deadlock. A member or manager may ask the court to dissolve the company. During the case, the court can issue injunctions, appoint a receiver or custodian, or, on good cause, order installment payments as part of another appropriate remedy it deems appropriate (section 605.0703).
When you compare your options, these are the points that usually change the choice:
- Whether the owners can break the deadlock themselves. Dissolution for LLC deadlock requires that the members cannot break it and that irreparable injury to the company is threatened or occurring (section 605.0702).
- Whether the agreement tries to keep you out of court. It cannot vary the statutory grounds for dissolution or unreasonably restrict your records rights, although a deadlock-breaking mechanism is allowed (section 605.0105).
- Whether you want out or want control. Filing for dissolution often leads to a buyout. If the parties cannot agree on a price within 60 days after the first purchase election, the court determines fair value and may, in an appropriate case, allow installment payments rather than only a lump-sum result; that can spread tax recognition across multiple years (section 605.0706).
- Whether the company is a corporation. A court may dissolve a corporation when the directors are deadlocked and the shareholders cannot break it (section 607.1430). Instead, it may appoint a custodian or provisional director, or order the petitioner's shares purchased (section 607.1434). Florida courts generally try to preserve viable businesses when another remedy can break the deadlock instead of forcing liquidation, much as they do in real estate ownership and management disputes across Broward County.
A worked example (hypothetical)
This is an invented example for illustration, not a past matter. Two owners each hold 50% of a Broward County limited liability company. The company is manager-managed, and one owner is the sole manager. For two years it paid quarterly distributions. This year the manager stopped them, citing "reinvestment," and the other owner's requests for financial statements go unanswered. If that conflict with one member drags on, it can also strain vendors, employees, or customers and adversely affect the business. The operating agreement has a buy-sell clause but no distribution schedule.
The stopped payments alone may not be a breach. Before dissolution, a member is entitled to a distribution only if the company decides to make one (section 605.0404), and the company cannot distribute if it would fail Florida's insolvency tests (section 605.0405). But the manager owes loyalty and care to the company and its members and must act consistently with good faith and fair dealing (section 605.04091). Withholding money to pressure the other owner out would be judged against that standard.
The non-managing owner's first move is a written records demand that describes the financial and distribution information sought and the purpose: valuing her interest and evaluating the halt. If the company refuses, she can ask the circuit court to order inspection. With the records in hand, she can decide whether the deadlock sale provision should be initiated promptly under the operating agreement before any court finding on deadlock. If that deadlock provision functions like a shoot-out, any buyout offer should be reviewed against the parties' actual access to capital so neither side is forced into an unfair sale. For the provision to control instead of dissolution or a court-ordered buyout, it must be initiated and effectuated under the agreement's notice and timing requirements. If the deadlock continues and the company is being harmed, a petition for dissolution remains the backstop, and the company or the manager could then elect to buy her interest at fair value. A Florida attorney should confirm how the current statutes and the agreement's language apply to any real situation, and resources like the firm's Florida business and real estate insights and case studies can help owners understand common patterns before they meet with counsel.
Questions readers also ask
Can I force my co-owner to buy me out?
Not directly, unless your agreement gives you a put right or a buy-sell trigger, and a court filing is not always the first step because the operating agreement may require a sale process or other deadlock provision first. But if you petition to dissolve for deadlock, the company or the other members may elect to buy your interest instead, and the court sets fair value if you cannot agree (section 605.0706). The company or other members may buy out the petitioning member instead of the dissolution proceeding continuing to liquidation.
Am I entitled to see the books?
Yes, within limits. Members can inspect and copy required company records, and an operating agreement cannot unreasonably restrict those rights (section 605.0410). Broader requests in a manager-managed LLC must be made in a record, be specific, and be tied to your interest as a member.
What does judicial dissolution actually do in a Florida LLC?
A dissolved LLC continues only to wind up its affairs (section 605.0709). Courts also have other tools: during the case, a court may appoint a receiver or custodian or order another remedy it deems appropriate (section 605.0703).
Does withholding distributions breach the agreement?
It depends on the agreement. If it requires distributions, stopping them may be a breach you can enforce directly (section 605.0801). If it is silent, distributions are generally at the company's discretion, but those managing the company must still act in good faith (section 605.04091).
Your next step
The Elliot Legal Group represents clients in Florida business disputes, including partner and shareholder disputes, LLC deadlocks, withheld distributions, records demands, buyouts, mediation, arbitration, and dissolution, as part of its business law practice. Before you trigger a buy-sell clause or file anything, it helps to have the operating agreement read against the facts. For Florida LLC members, an early review of the operating agreement and any separate member agreement can identify required mediation, arbitration, or deadlock procedures before litigation. Have the documents from the checklist above ready, and be prepared to explain what you want: a buyout, a sale, or a working company again.
Contact The Elliot Legal Group's Fort Lauderdale business law team to discuss your situation. To start, request an Initial Case Assessment. On the first call, a member of the firm's team conducts an initial interview under attorney supervision to understand your company, your co-owner, and what has happened so far. Attorney legal review follows. Document review, including review of your operating agreement, begins only after a signed retainer and payment, and the firm's Fort Lauderdale business, real estate, and wills and trusts practice outlines how consultations move from initial assessment through resolution.
Author: Gavin Elliot, Esq., The Elliot Legal Group (bio) and team of South Florida business and real estate professionals. Reviewing attorney: Gavin Elliot.
This article is general information, not legal advice, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Statutes cited are current as of November 2026. Every company and situation is different; consult a licensed Florida attorney about your specific facts.
